How would Trump or Biden deal with grid hacking threats?


How would Trump or Biden deal with grid hacking threats?

Christian Vasquez, E&E News reporter

Published: Tuesday, November 3, 2020

President Trump and Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden have a few competing plans for the nation’s cybersecurity — though experts say they largely expect the next U.S. president to stay the course. Graphic by E&E News/Jason Goulding/Flickr(photo)

The next U.S. president will face a growing number of grid cybersecurity threats as new energy technologies emerge and attacks on critical infrastructure become more common. But experts are questioning whether President Trump or Democratic nominee Joe Biden will prioritize a thorny issue that tends to stay out of the limelight until hackers strike.

“I think the incoming administration is very much aware of the threat,” retired NATO Supreme Allied Commander Gen. Wesley Clark said in an interview. “But is it something that we can push front and center? That’s the question.”

Clark pointed out that “we’re dealing with the most complex engineering, human system ever devised: the U.S. electricity grid.”

“Even simple problems can hide in so many different places and give access to this grid, which could be attacked, disrupted or disabled” by cyberthreats, he added.

Hackers are no longer shying away from attacking critical infrastructure: Last Wednesday, the Department of Homeland Security’s cyber office and the FBI warned of “ransomware” cyberattacks against the health sector with several hospitals already affected. The alert raised the specter of potentially deadly ransomware attacks by hackers who have historically held off from targeting U.S. health care providers, which are already facing strained resources during the coronavirus pandemic.

The U.S. electric grid is also threatened. Hackers backed by nations like Iran and Russia have continued to probe the power grid, and utilities have reported steadily increasing numbers of attempted cyber intrusions over the years.

The Trump administration has ramped up a “name and shame” strategy that calls out state-backed hackers allegedly behind some of the most egregious cyberattacks in recent history. Some experts have criticized the approach as an ineffective deterrent, while others suggest there aren’t many alternatives besides economic sanctions or working with allies to set international norms of behavior in cyberspace (Energywire, Oct. 20).

Biden, meanwhile, has championed a plan to accelerate adoption of clean energy and reach a carbon-free grid by 2035. That would require an energy sector overhaul, and cybersecurity experts worry that adding new technologies to the grid without building in security can introduce vulnerabilities. That’s particularly true with distributed electricity resources like solar panels and electric vehicles, which often depend on internet-facing devices. But some say Biden’s plans for the electricity sector could also open the door to additional security measures.

“The Biden campaign has certainly talked about a large infrastructure spend for clean energy technology: building out EV charging stations, decarbonizing the grid,” said Casey Herman, U.S. power and utilities leader for PwC. “Anytime there’s an opportunity now to modernize the grid, cybersecurity protection will be built into it.”

Representatives from the Trump and Biden campaigns did not respond to requests for comment.

Cybersecurity is often trumpeted as a nonpartisan issue, and there is little political disagreement that critical infrastructure should be protected from hackers.

But there are some fault lines, particularly when it comes to foreign affairs. The past four years have seen a dramatic increase in tensions between China and the U.S., and Trump’s trade war with Beijing could provoke retaliation in cyberspace, experts warn.

Both Trump and Biden have accused China of state-sponsored efforts to steal U.S. intellectual property. Biden has his own experience in combating Beijing’s hacking attempts: As vice president under Obama, Biden was closely involved with an intelligence community push to halt IP theft.

“The broader issue is how do you look at the geopolitical landscape? What changes from a political tension perspective in one administration versus another?” said Joe Nocera, cyber and privacy innovation institute leader at PwC. “Does that cause one of the nation-state actors to be more or less aggressive as a result? That’s the thing I would be watching.”

Executive action

A few Trump administration cyber policy changes have fallen flat or been met with skepticism in his first term, including a May 1 executive order aimed at securing the grid supply chain from backdoor cybersecurity threats. Trump directed the Energy Department to draft a ban on high-risk, foreign-made grid equipment, but the agency has missed deadlines and diluted its planned response (Energywire, Oct. 13). The order also faced industry criticism: The proposed changes took electricity leaders by surprise, and the order’s vagueness forced much of the sector to wait and see.

Top Trump officials have also not yet acted on many recommendations from the bipartisan, congressionally mandated Cyberspace Solarium Commission, which issued a report this spring with nearly 80 cybersecurity action items, including calls for the White House to create a national cyber director role.

The solarium report could offer something of a cyber road map for a potential Biden administration. But Trump could still act on its findings as well.

“Regardless of the election, the administration is changing. A second-term Trump is way different than a first-term Trump,” said Robert M. Lee, CEO of industrial cybersecurity firm Dragos Inc. and member of DOE’s Electricity Advisory Committee.

The National Commission on Grid Resilience also released a report with grid-focused cybersecurity recommendations for the incoming administration.

“Grid integrity is an issue that must be a top priority for policymakers, and it can never become a partisan topic,” said former Rep. Darrell Issa (R-Calif.), co-chair of the commission. “Regardless of which party wins the presidential or congressional elections, we must work together to secure any vulnerabilities we have.”

‘Out of time’

The next occupant of the Oval Office will also have to contend with the growing concern that federal regulations alone are not enough to protect utilities from cyberattacks. Grid overseers at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission released a white paper proposing incentives for cybersecurity investments in the bulk electric system (Greenwire, Aug. 31). The report acknowledged the limits of federal critical infrastructure protection standards that include detailed cybersecurity requirements for utilities. Fast-paced technological developments — and the cyberthreats that accompany that evolution — quickly outpace the development of new standards that can take years to be enacted, the white paper said.

A Biden administration could be more willing to look at additional regulations and take a more expansive view on the government role in protecting critical infrastructure, while the Trump administration is likely to lean toward less regulation with a greater focus on the role of the private sector.

“I think you could have a little bit of both, but you gotta at least do both,” Lee said.

U.S. presidents face a delicate balancing act when pursuing public-private partnerships tied to the power grid, where the overwhelming majority of infrastructure is owned and operated by private companies. Bigger utilities may have the resources to fend off nation-backed hackers, experts say, but smaller power providers rarely have that luxury. Both types of companies have called for boosting federal partnership around threat intelligence sharing, as utilities have warned that keeping too much information classified could leave them out of the loop on the latest threats.

Grid security is not completely reliant on the outcome of the race for the White House, said Clark. The upcoming Congress and the electric industry will have to ensure grid security remains a top concern.

“This is a priority. It may not be as high as other priorities … and that has to be fought out in the budgeting process” in Congress, said Clark. “When the issue of priorities is raised, much will depend upon the electricity industry itself.”

While industry experts have said that there has been significant improvement in grid security in recent years, they also warn that it’s not yet enough. Many of the proposals working their way through Congress and agencies like FERC will take years to pass, and even longer before they are taken up by utilities. For many cybersecurity experts, the industry is running far behind.

“There has definitely been a sense of urgency,” said Dragos’ Lee. “We can debate all day long about energy attacks — we are out of time, we have to do something.”

Twitter: @chrismvasq Email: [email protected]


Article by Christian Vasquez, E&E News reporter.


In Other News…

NSF and SpaceX Finalize Radio Spectrum Coordination Agreement

This news article was originally published on on January 10, 2023.Credit: NRAO/AUI/NSF, Jeff HellermanThe National Science Foundation (NSF) and SpaceX have finalized a radio spectrum coordination agreement to limit interference from the company’s Starlink...

ALMA and JWST Reveal Galactic Shock is Shaping Stephan’s Quintet in Mysterious Ways

This news article was originally published on on January 9, 2023.Credit: ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO)/JWST/ P. Appleton (Caltech), B.Saxton (NRAO/AUI/NSF)Shockwaves resulting from the violent collision between an intruder galaxy and Stephan’s Quintet are helping...

ALMA Scientists Find Pair of Black Holes Dining Together in Nearby Galaxy Merger

This news article was originally published on on January 9, 2023.Credit: ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), M. Weiss (NRAO/AUI/NSF)While studying a nearby pair of merging galaxies using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA)— an international observatory...

Hydrogen Masers Reveal New Secrets of a Massive Star to ALMA Scientists

This news article was originally published on on January 9, 2023.Credit: ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), M. Weiss (NRAO/AUI/NSF)Scientists used the unique hydrogen radio recombination lines on MWC 349A to reveal hidden collimated jets While using the Atacama Large...

Northwest Indian College Hosts Inaugural Cosmovisions of the Pacific Meeting

Bellingham, Washington – Over 14,000 years ago, Indigenous groups in the Pacific traveled by boat, guided by starlight, and likely settled the West Coast of the Americas. Today, Indigenous and non-indigenous people gathered at Northwest Indian College (NWIC) to...

AUI Board of Trustees Elects Christine Wilson as Board Chair and William Harris as Vice Chair

AUI Board of Trustees Elects Christine Wilson as Board Chair and William Harris as Vice Chair Washington, D.C.— The AUI Board of Trustees met at AUI’s Dunn Loring office in Vienna, VA September 22 and 23. Following President Adam Cohen’s overview of AUI, and reports...

Heising—Simons Foundation Partners with AUI and the IAU to Boost Gender Equity Programs for Young Astronomers

The Heising–Simons Foundation (HSF) has awarded $126,500 to Associated Universities, Inc. (AUI) and the International Astronomical Union (IAU) to support two programs: the Women and Girls in Astronomy project and the IAU Junior Member Travel Grant Fund. Women and...

New NSF Funded Project Will Study How Podcasts Can Support Inclusive STEM Learning

[Washington, D.C.] Tumble Media, in partnership with Associated Universities Inc (AUI), Oregon State University (OSU) and Independence Science, has been awarded a $1 million grant by the National Science Foundation (NSF) Division Of Research On Learning. The team will...

AUI and NRAO Announce 2022 NAC Bridge Scholarship Recipients

This news article was originally published on on July 5, 2022.AUI and the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO) have announced the recipients of the 2022 AUI Board of Trustees NAC Bridge Scholarship Award. Now in its second year, the scholarship...

You are now leaving AUI

You will be redirected to the related partnering organization's website.

You will be redirected to
in 4 seconds...

Click the link above to continue or CANCEL