Coverage on National Commision on Grid Resilience’s (NCGR) Latest Report

The following is press coverage on the NCGR’s new report, courtesy of UtilityDive.com.

 

Dive Brief:

A new report from the National Commission on Grid Resilience (NCGR) calls for declassifying and giving utilities greater access to information about threats facing the United States’ electric system, to better protect critical infrastructure and communicate the extent of the risk to the public and decision-makers.

The report recommends Congress develop a new independent agency staffed by cybersecurity and defense experts, and “a profound overhaul of the communication of classified threat information to utilities.”

The call for greater information sharing with the electric industry is not new, but security experts questioned the need for a new federal agency when similar work is already being done by the Electricity Subsector Coordinating Council (ESCC) and NERC’s Electricity Information Sharing and Analysis Center (E-ISAC).

 

Dive Insight:

There is some risk in declassifying threat information, experts concede, as it may tip off foreign adversaries to the electric sector’s defense capabilities and the United States’ information gathering processes. However, as attempts to disrupt the power grid become more sophisticated, NCGR’s analysis views this as a necessary tradeoff to better inform the industry of the growing threat.

“This is a national security threat, but it’s not widely recognized by the American people. And even the people who should be charged with protecting us from it, often don’t get the information they need,” retired General Wesley Clark said Thursday at a public virtual event unveiling the commission’s recommendations.

Clark is an NCGR commissioner, along with former Republican Rep. Darrell Issa from California; Kevin Knobloch, a former DOE chief of staff who is now president of Anbaric offshore wind development entity New York OceanGrid LLC; Gueta Maria Mezzetti, a former member of the Pentagon’s Energy Security Executive Council; and several others. The group is chartered and supported by Woodstar Labs, a non-profit technology and analysis firm owned by Associated Universities Inc.

The report includes nine recommendations and calls for federal lawmakers to direct the Department of Energy (DOE), Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the Director of National Intelligence to “establish a central clearinghouse and decisional node for communicating full and accurate threat information to bulk power system operators and electric utilities.”

Congress should establish a National Resilient Grid Authority to help test for and protect against electric system vulnerabilities, according to the report. The new agency would be independent and staffed by rotating appointments of security experts from both the private and public sector, the group said.

Clark said the government needs to build on the current Cybersecurity Risk Information Sharing Program (CRISP), which is a collaboration between the E-ISAC, DOE and the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.

CRISP disseminates threat information, Clark said, “but it’s not fast enough, and it’s not detailed enough to take responsive action.”

DOE did not respond to requests for comment on CRISP’s capabilities.

NERC, in an emailed statement, said that timely and actionable information sharing “are essential to grid security,” and said it works with E-ISAC to”operate a full suite of products and services designed to provide threat intelligence and coordination to North American utilities on a range of cyber and physical security threats.”

Along with CRISP, those tools include NERC alerts, All Points Bulletins and Critical Broadcast Program calls. NERC and E-ISAC communications with utilities “focus on sharing security threats and mitigations in near-real time,” a spokesman said in an email.

But according to Clark, DOE, DHS and and industry entities “need expanded powers” to “name and shame” hostile actions and attack attempts, with an emphasis on the frequency of intrusions.

“I know this risks indicating how much we know about adversaries, but it’s a risk we have to take as a nation because we’ve got to get the American people and our private sector institutions to understand what we’re up against,” Clark said.

Security experts agree the need for threat information sharing is essential, but questioned the efficacy of a new federal agency and warned there can be danger in providing the industry with too much data.

Any communication overhaul should leverage existing self-governance mechanisms within the industry, including ESCC and E-ISAC, said Shawn Wallace, vice president of energy at IronNet Cybersecurity. That approach is endorsed by the NCGR recommendations, but Wallace balked at creation of a new federal agency.

“We do not need a new group or federal agency to step into this function when the E-ISAC is already performing this role in the sector,” he said in an email. He agreed with calls for real-time information sharing networks and action tools that “reach directly into system control rooms.”

“In order to meet the future threats, information sharing needs to be automated and real time,” Wallace said. “Utilities don’t need more information, they need better resolution on the information that’s already out there. …If they’re taking in too much information it can become diluting and they’ll struggle to get value from it.”

The call to more quickly disseminate threat information to the utility sector is not new. Last year, NERC President and CEO Jim Robb called for the federal government to accelerate the declassification of industry-relevant information regarding cybersecurity threats and consider broadening the availability of security clearances for the energy sector.

Other NCGR security recommendations include development of a nationwide network of resilience-focused microgrid test beds, changes to both on- and offshore transmission planning and a strategic reserve of grid transformers and other critical infrastructure.

Article by UtilityDive.com’s Robert Walton.

 

In Other News…

Cyber Expert Wins FBI Community Leadership Award

Robert R. Wells, special agent in charge of the Charlotte Division of the FBI has chosen a local cyber expert as the 2020 Director’s Community Leadership Award (DCLA) recipient for North Carolina. Torry Crass has been an invaluable partner to the FBI Charlotte field office since 2013.

2021 AUI Scholarship Recipients

Below are the fourteen winners of the 2021 AUI Scholarship conducted by International Scholarship and Tuition Services, Inc. These students will each receive an award of $3,500 per year to aid in defraying expenses at the college or university of their choice.

ITL Development Director: “We are convinced that our proposal is solid and meets all the requirements”

In an interview with Nueva Mining and Energy Magazine, Ricardo Raineri, Director of Development of the Chilean Institute of Clean Technologies (ITL) refers to the criticism that has hovered over Corfo’s decision, arguing that “it is essential to understand and emphasize that our proposal is based on an open platform model ”.

West Virginia Students Contact International Space Station LIVE

Friday, May 7th at 8:00 AM EDT, students in rural West Virginia will experience this once in a lifetime opportunity. Green Bank Elementary-Middle School (GBEMS) will be contacting astronaut Mark Vande Hei on the International Space Station (ISS).

The Universe just Became More Accessible: Free Software for Exploring the Universe Through Sound

Today free software has been released to help the blind and visually impaired (BIV) explore the universe through sound. With the support from the National Science Foundation’s STEM+C program, Innovators Developing Accessible Tools for Astronomy (IDATA) brought together nearly 200 BIV and sighted students, teachers, astronomers and programmers from across the Nation to create this innovative software called Afterglow Access.

Nueva Mineria covers the importance of ICTL’s Open Science model pioneered by AUI

The ICTL is a Chilean clean technology institute that is committed to developing innovations in the mining, power, battery, manufacturing, and related industrial sectors. The Open Science model allows a larger community to access R&D facilities based on the merit of their proposals.

VIDEO: Multi-wavelength Observations Reveal Impact of Black Hole on M87 Galaxy

In 2019, a worldwide collaboration of scientists used a global collection of radio telescopes called the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) to make the first-ever image of a black hole — the supermassive black hole at the core of the galaxy M87, some 55 million light-years from Earth.

ACEAP Alumna Selected as Astronaut for SpaceX

Sian Procter, a participant in the Astronomy in Chile Educator Ambassadors Program (ACEAP) in 2016, has been selected as an astronaut by SpaceX. The Inspiration4 mission, scheduled to launch sometime after 15 September 2021, will orbit Earth for three days and conduct a variety of experiments.

New Images Reveal Magnetic Structures Near Supermassive Black Hole

The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) — the worldwide collaboration that produced the first image of a black hole in 2019 — has produced a new image showing details of the magnetic fields in the region closest to the supermassive black hole at the core of the galaxy M87. The new work is providing astronomers with important clues about how powerful jets of material can be produced in that region.

After Long Shutdown, Giant Radio Telescope Array Set to Resume Observations

The Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), a set of 66 radio astronomy dishes perched high in the Chilean Andes, was hit hard by the pandemic. It shut down on 22 March 2020 and has remained silent ever since—far longer than most scientific facilities....

You are now leaving AUI

You will be redirected to the related partnering organization's website.

You will be redirected to
in 4 seconds...

Click the link above to continue or CANCEL